Earlville mayor charged with DWI after allegedly running over mailbox

Damage to a yard and a destroyed mailbox along Earlville Road, in Hamilton following an Oct. 3 crash. Earlville Mayor Justice Mitchell was charged with DWI following the incident by the NY State Police. (Submitted photo)

EARLVILLE — A loud bang brought an Earlville resident out of his home on the afternoon of Oct. 3.

According to Shawn Ashton, a driver appeared to go completely off the road and took out his mailbox, which had approximately 200 pounds of sand in the base. When the driver of the truck pulling a camper failed to stop at the scene, Ashton said he contacted police.

According to a statement from New York State Police Troop D, a preliminary investigation determined that a vehicle traveling southwest on Earlville Road exited the roadway and struck a mailbox at a residence on Earlville Road in the Town of Hamilton. They reported the operator subsequently fled the scene.

Story Continues Below

Troopers responding to the scene reportedly located debris from the vehicle and followed evidence that led them to a parked vehicle on East Main Street in the Village of Earlville.

Police identified the driver as Justice Mitchell. According to NY Troopers, signs of impairment were observed. Mitchell was reportedly taken into custody and transported to the State Police barracks in Morrisville. A chemical test was administered, and a blood alcohol content (BAC) of 0.22 percent, more than twice the legal limit, was reported by police.

Mitchell was arrested and charged with three traffic violations, driving while intoxicated and aggravated driving while intoxicated for having a BAC of 0.18 percent or higher.

Story Continues Below

Mitchell was serving as a trustee on the Village of Earlville Board at the time of the arrest. Just 10 days after the incident, Mayor Tom Taylor announced that he would be stepping down, and Mitchell was appointed to take over as mayor of the Village of Earlville.

Ashton said he believes that people are innocent until proven guilty; however, he expressed frustration with the situation. “We have this hit and run and the next thing I know he is appointed as the mayor. I don’t think he should have accepted the position,” he said.

Ashton’s sentiment was reiterated by community member Greg Marriam at the November meeting of the Village Board. “How could you consider sitting at that table and accepting the position after that incident?” Marriam asked.

Mitchell stated that he had accepted the position before any allegations were made; however, he was officially appointed mayor at the Oct. 13 board meeting.

Story Continues Below

Ashton said Mitchell has been in contact since the incident and did make restitution for the damage to the mailbox.

No injuries were reported as a result of the crash. Mitchell was released with an appearance ticket for Town of Hamilton Court. The mayor was contacted and asked to comment on the events, but as of press time this morning, he had not responded.



Comments

There are 0 comments for this article

Leave a Reply

Please Login to post a comment.